Since 1917

A reputation that travelled

The American Coney Island Hot Dog has been a favourite with Detroiters and visitors for over a century. As Detroiters have moved to other parts of the country, and as visitors have returned to their respective states, the American’s reputation has spread throughout the country. Over the years, American has received countless requests from people who wanted to have the Coney Islands shipped to them — either for their own restaurants, their own consumption, or for parties and special events.

One of the most-frequently-mentioned comments that former Detroiters who have moved out of town say is: one of the things they miss most about Detroit is Coney Islands from the American Coney Island downtown on Lafayette Street.

Why it tastes the way it does

One of the reasons for the great popularity of the American’s Coney Islands is the high-quality, specially-seasoned, natural casing hot dogs that have always been served at the American. Another reason is the Coney Island chili sauce, which is specially prepared using a secret recipe the Keros family developed decades ago. And, of course, the topping of fine mustard and fresh, chopped sweet onions adds the final touch to the distinctive overall taste and flavour of the Coney Island hot dog, which is served in a warm, steamed bun.

No wonder the American Coney Island hot dog has been such a tantalizing treat to the palate that’s still hard to beat after all these years.

The two on Lafayette

Nickel coneys proved popular and profitable, so Gust Keros brought his brother William over from Greece. William learned the business at the American and, when the storefront next door became available, started the Lafayette Coney Island. The two have sat side by side ever since. Detroit has never fully settled the argument, and neither restaurant has ever really wanted it settled.